|
Post by iamafan on Jun 23, 2007 21:38:08 GMT -5
well ithink he kind of knew he was alive.
|
|
|
Post by katieloveshp on Jun 24, 2007 12:52:30 GMT -5
okay. i think that dumbledore was actaully pleading for snape to kill him. not because his hand was hurting or because he was old or because he had just drank that potion. it was probably because he knew about the unbreakable vow that snape made to Narcissa and Dumbledore knew that snape would die if he didn't kill dumbledore. [[because that's what draco was supposed to do.
soo. if snape had died then there wouldn't have been a spy for the OOTP and then they would basically be outta luck.
and dumbledore knew that if he died and snape or malfoy did it then snape would be able to continue being a spy. i hope this has made sense.
so in a short note
snape killed dumbledore bc he had to continue being a spy for the order. dumbledore knew it and he wanted to die if it came down to that. snape is good!!! not evil although he is a vile little git.
|
|
|
Post by iamafan on Jun 25, 2007 3:29:52 GMT -5
what?thats totally confusing.
|
|
lupinlover
Witch/Wizard
I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!!!! [H:4]
Posts: 436
|
Post by lupinlover on Jun 25, 2007 14:39:39 GMT -5
So your saying that Snape killed Dumbledore b/c Dumbledore wanted to keep Snape alive to stay spy for the Order?
|
|
|
Post by nutz4hpotter6 on Jun 25, 2007 14:54:23 GMT -5
Yes I think that is what they are trying to say. I am still up in the air about this. I am right now reading the Great Severus Debate. Maybe when I get done reading it I will have an opinion or I'll just be more confused.
|
|
|
Post by iamafan on Jun 25, 2007 20:41:56 GMT -5
there's just to many possibilities.
|
|
|
Post by snuffles on Jun 26, 2007 4:26:28 GMT -5
ok u know how i said that i think snape is really innocent, well i have a new speculation. im rereading the books to try and gather new theories and refresh my memory for july 21 and im reading HBP atm and i just came up with something.
dumbledore knew that the defence against the dark arts job was jinxed as he said in the book and yet he made snape DADA teacher. if he knew the job was jinxed and he thought that snape was in fact on their side, why would he want to get rid of him by making him DADA teacher? now im not saying this means snape is guilty because i still have a feeling he's innocent, but what do u guys think?? i found it very interesting...
|
|
|
Post by iamafan on Jun 26, 2007 5:43:21 GMT -5
i noticed that too,maybe he was beginning to doubt snape........
|
|
lupinlover
Witch/Wizard
I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!!!! [H:4]
Posts: 436
|
Post by lupinlover on Jun 26, 2007 9:06:17 GMT -5
Or maybe Dumbledore just wanted a full-time spy. Or Dumbledore might have known that LV would have eventually killed Snape for teaching there with Dumbledore.
|
|
|
Post by iamafan on Jun 26, 2007 11:57:18 GMT -5
we wont know till the next book.
|
|
lupinlover
Witch/Wizard
I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!!!! [H:4]
Posts: 436
|
Post by lupinlover on Jun 26, 2007 12:01:06 GMT -5
Yeah. The next/last book will tell us for sure.
|
|
|
Post by iamafan on Jun 26, 2007 14:21:28 GMT -5
i cant wait!!!
|
|
|
Post by iloveuandhp2 on Jun 27, 2007 22:54:40 GMT -5
So your saying that Snape killed Dumbledore b/c Dumbledore wanted to keep Snape alive to stay spy for the Order? ~~~posted by lupinlover
i thhink that too but its too confusin so im just waiting till the boooks come out and i know im really late with this post
|
|
|
Post by iloveuandhp2 on Jun 27, 2007 23:27:07 GMT -5
yeah that makes sense that dd was begining to distrust snape so maybe he gave him the job in hope that he would die or maybe he was rewarding snape for being loyal to him but that brings up the part about spinners end
|
|
|
Post by iamafan on Jun 28, 2007 2:10:51 GMT -5
i say either way he killed dd.
|
|