Why Harry/Harry's Scar is NOT a horcrux

[nutz4hpotter6]

That is why I think he had to be doing the spell at the same time of doing the AK curse. V would of had to have been doing the Horcrux as he got hit by the rebounded AK curse. I just don't see how that is possible though.

[Leigh]

I don't see how it's possible either.

Something I'm beginning to wonder about. The AK curse rebounded on him, and it would have killed him, had it not been for the Horcruxes. Could the horcrux we can't figure out be the horcrux that Voldy is using??

In any case, the part of V's soul that was in him before the downfall was killed. That leaves one less, wouldn't it?

Just a curiosity, I may be very wrong.

[nutz4hpotter6]

I get what you are trying to say. It took me a while but I got it. It always said that he was a shell of his former self (or something like that). That is a possibility until someone can prove us wrong (which I would guess would be Sala). That does give us something more to think about.

[Leigh]

Yes, we need Sala, just to see if she can prove us wrong. She probably can, but, still, it's an idea that he had to use one of his horcruxes to not die when the AK curse rebounded.

Since the AK curse (usually) leaves no mark, can the scar be from when V transferred some of his powers rather than from the AK curse?? Just wondering.

[nutz4hpotter6]

I don't know. The scar is not from Lily's love protection when she died so that could very well be how he got the scar. I was talking to a coworker today about the title and the scar. She doesn't think Harry is going to die. It was fun discussing this idea about this horcrux.

[Leigh]

I can't wait to get back to school. In my seventh hour, there's a guy that likes Harry Potter as well, so I'll discuss this all with him.

That's just what I was thinking, since they do say the the AK leaves no mark, so a scar would be unusual for that curse.

[nutz4hpotter6]

Wow you are still off from school. How lucky can you get. Let me know what he thinks about this theory. I love discussing these with people just to get different ideas and perspectives.

[Leigh]

I go back tomorrow, unfortunately. But I get to see all of my friends.

I wonder if he's come up with any theories. I'll have to ask. I like hearing theories people come up with, and, of course, making my own theories.

Yay, my grandma made me a Gryffindor Scarf and she just finished it. Hehe. Now I have two.

[nutz4hpotter6]

That is great. I wish I had a scarf from one of the houses. You should wear both of them at the same time.

[Accio Padfoot! Refo]

leighpotter13 said:

I do disagree with you on one thing. I think Harry's scar is very valuable.

Oh well, Yes, it is valuable for us and for everyone, but when I said it wasn't, I meant it from Voldemort's point of view, I mean, Voldemort would never think that Harry's scar is "worthy" enough to hold a part of his soul, not like the founders belongings, the cup and the locket and the other stuff, these are valuable to Voldemort, but as for Harry, his scar is not valuable in the way that makes it worthy, and Voldemort himself said in book 5 something about Harry not being worthy, even Bella did.
Err...guess when he said the word "Voldemort" and she said something like "how dare you say his name with your unworthy lips".
and when LV asked Harry for the prophecy and Harry said it was broken, he said something like he can see that Harry was saying the truth through his unworthy eyes.
That is, if Voldemort loathes Harry that much he will not make his scar a horcrux.
So am sorry for the misunderstanding, I should have explained more.

[nutz4hpotter6]

You are forgiven Refo. I don't know if by mistake the scar is a Horcrux. We don't know how to make one do we. It was never revealed in the 6th book ( at least I don't think so.)

[Aleysha Potter (ilovemagic06)]

I've re-read that part about the Horcruxes a few times ((I could of missed something because it has been a while since I've read Half-Blood Prince)) and all it really says that it's a complicated process.

At first I thought Harry's scar was a Horcrux after I read the sixth book, probably because I was so excited and can't wait to see what will happen now, and grieving over Dumbledore's death *tear* but then it can't be because like you all said and its true, he's trying to kill Harry because he's a really big threat to him so he wouldn't make a Horcrux out of him.

Hang on, wait a minute! This just came to me! The last Horcrux will most likely be very well protected and kept very close to Voldemort so I think, the last Horcrux, could be his very own wand. There is a chance, because we all know Voldemort can perform magic without his wand. Anyway that's what I think, its definately not Harry's scar though.

[nutz4hpotter6]

That could be right but what about when they battled in the 4th book. Their wands met so if his wand was a Horcrux wouldn't the Horcrux come out of it. I don't know just was wondering.

I really think that the last Horcrux is either at Godric's Hollow. If it isn't there then I would say it could be his scar. I don't think it is but I can't think of anything else that could be.

I am now going to have to re-read the HBP soon.

[Accio Padfoot! Refo]

Voldemort's wand being a horcrux is a good theory, but as you said Nutz, wouldnt the soul in it come out when it contacted with Harry's wand?
Hmm...It's difficult to guess what the last horcrux could be, emmm...I guess I'll be spending a long time now thinking of possible horcruxes.

[nutz4hpotter6]

You and me both. I know that when I finally re-read the Half Blood Prince I will have to try and pay attention to detail. Ha ha that is hard for me to do.